Oil And Water

Oil And Water is the third episode of Survivor: Hawaii

Challenges
Reward Challenge: Idol Hands One member from both tribes will hold a handled pedestal with an idol on top. The goal is to knock the other person's idol from their pedestal. The first tribe to score four points wins reward. Reward: A choice between comfort items or function items. Winners: TBA

Reward Challenge: Lake Launch One at a time, five tribe members would slide down a water slide. They would then swim out to retrieve a bag of puzzle pieces, then run up stairs on the hill they slid down to drop their bag off. Once all five bags were retrieved, the remaining castaway would use the puzzle pieces to solve a puzzle which will ask a riddle. The answer to the riddle is a combination to open a locked chest, which holds an axe. The first tribe to open their chest and use the axe to cut a rope that would raise their tribe's flag would win. Winners: TBA

Night 6
The episode opens to the remaining members of the purple Kahoolawe tribe trudging back into camp in a desperate and defeated manner.

Marcus (bitterly): Wow guys... I sure as hell wasn't expecting that.

No one says anything at first. Molly, sensing the potential for the situation to turn both awkward and ugly, slinks away to the safety of the tribe shelter.

Marcus can be seen walking to the side with Pierce as Derek confronts Cindy, assuming that she voted for him.

Derek (interrogating her): Did you vote for me tonight?

Cindy (seeing no point in lying): Yeah.

Derek sighs frustrated as he shakes his head.

Derek (sharply): Why? What's the point?

Cindy (taken back by his sudden aggression): I'm on the bottom it's as simple as that and you seemed like the best target, I didn't get told anything about Titan or Molly being voted out. I thought for sure I was going home.

Derek: So you voted for me?

Cindy nods without saying anything, not wanting to cause further aggravation to Derek in case it turns sour. As she doesn't say anything, Derek continues.

Derek: I know that you betrayed me too.

Cindy: Meaning?

Derek: Marcus told me that you told him about my past career in the NRL.

Cindy nods and breathes in and out slowly, considering her next words carefully.

Cindy (cautiously): He backed me into a corner, there was nothing I could do. I had to tell him because I thought I was going home if I didn't. I didn't know he was just interrogating me for information and that it wasn't me.

Derek (angrily): Well then, I can vote you out now so you better watch your back.

Derek turns to walk back to the shelter and turn in for the night as Cindy sighs.

The camera focuses on Cindy snapping some twigs and throwing them into the fire before it cuts to Pierce and Marcus talking a little further down on the beach as the latter tries to figure out what happened.

Marcus (annoyed): What's going on I thought we had an alliance? It was you, Sarah and I until the very end but you voted out a loyal number and a huge vote shield. Explain to me why that's a good idea.

Pierce holds his hands up to Marcus indicating for him to calm down before Pierce can explain.

Pierce: Titan was volatile and a bully. I am here to play a game but there are somethings I just can't sit by and agree with. I'm not going to let someone like that control the vote and I know Sarah is the same.

Marcus: But you aren't thinking things through properly this was a huge risk.

Pierce (doubtful): Was it? Because I know we still have the majority. Derek will easily side with us and that's a four to two advantage. I don't think we have to worry.

Marcus sighs and nods, finally accepting what Pierce is trying to tell him.

Marcus (calming down): Ok, ok. I trust you and I trust Sarah but if you're going to do something like that again, please tell me.

Pierce (nodding): We will, don't lose any sleep over it.

Marcus solemnly nods as Pierce leaves him to head back to the shelter.

A shot from the shore facing the water shows Marcus sitting in the centre of the screen looking out to the water as sand reaches out either side of him, uninterrupted by trees or vegetation.

The camera focuses on Marcus for a little longer before fading out and cutting to the intro.

Day 7
The camera cuts back in to an aerial view of a large green field. In the centre of the field is a small round arena, enclosed by a wooden fence. It zooms in to show Probst standing in front of two tribe mats, a red and a purple one, with the arena behind him.

Jeff Probst: Come on in guys!

Kauai enters first lead by Kathy with Carl bringing up the rear and the flag. Kahoolawe follows shortly with Molly up front and Derek at the end.

Jeff Probst: Kauai, getting your first look at the new Kahoolawe tribe. Titan, voted off at the last tribal council.

Joe raises his eyebrows as Kathy opens her mouth in shock and looks over to Ali who is nodding with surprise. Molly grins as Derek rolls his eyes. After the Kauai tribe has enough time to soak up all that information Probst goes onto describe the challenge. He explains that the first tribe to score four points will win and that the winners will get to choose between comfort in the form of blankets, pillows, a few chairs and a hammock, or function in the form of tarp, a hammer, nails and twine. Probst tells Kauai they have to sit two people out and they choose Lily and Jacob. He gives the tribes a chance to strategise before they begin. Jeff Probst: MOLLY'S STATUE DROPS, KAUAI WINS REWARD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 * In round one, Carl verses Marcus and whilst Marcus does his best to intimidate Carl by swiping as much as possible, Carl easily knocks Marcus's statue off. Kauai leads, 1-0.
 * Ali competes with Cindy in round two. Cindy is very aggressive to begin with but Ali manages to dodge every attack. Eventually, Cindy leans too far forward and her statue falls off. Kauai leads, 2-0.
 * Derek comes up against Joe for round three. Derek takes his time, convinced that he'll win as Joe sizes up his competition. Suddenly, Joe tosses his idol into the air and slams into Derek, knocking his idol off before a shocked Derek can react. Kauai leads, 3-0.
 * Round four sees Sarah take on Kathy. They play it safe to start with but as son as Kathy's eyes look away, Sarah launches in and swipes Kathy's statue onto the ground. Kauai still leads, 3-1.
 * Zane steps into the arena to verse Pierce in round five. Zane acts confident but Pierce isn't deterred as the former throws his statue into the air and launches towards Pierce. Realising this, Pierce throws his statue up at the last second and Zane's hits the ground first. Kauai remains in front, 3-2.
 * In round six, Molly goes up against Didi and both are cagey to start with, keeping arms length from each other. Didi manages to get close a few times as she gains confidence but Molly manages to dodge each attack. Didi moves to Molly's side quickly and goes to swipe it from the side, resulting in Molly jumping back and losing her statue.

The Kauai tribe floods into the arena to celebrate as Didi joins them, beaming at the won. Molly gets up off the ground, annoyed, as Marcus rolls his eyes and shakes his head. Derek spits at the ground, frustrated by his tribes loss. After the tribes calm down, Probst addresses them.

Jeff Probst: Kauai, once again, congratulations. Reward is yours, but you have a choice. Comfort, or function, what's it gonna be?

Joe: We'll take function Jeff.

Jeff Probst (with a nod): Come and get it (Carl and Didi walk over to grab the function items). Kahoolawe, once again, got nothin' for ya, grab your stuff, head back to camp.

The Kahoolawe tribe nods, upset at yet another loss as the focus hones in on Derek.

The camera focuses on Derek, Molly and Cindy and then zooms out.

The camera cuts back in to the Kauai camp where the victors of the reward challenge are marching triumphantly up the beach. Carl carries the tarp as Didi holds the hammer, nails and twine.

Carl sets down the tarp and Didi sets down the hammer and nails and twine on the shelter.

Zane (to the tribe): What do you guys say we get this tarp at now so if it rains tonight we have some protection.

Joe (nodding): Sounds good man, let's get it up there!

Zane: Good good, it'd be helpful if we could have all hands on deck for this one.

The other tribe members nod and agree apart from Kathy who just watches on with an annoyed expression.

As Zane helps Carl hold up part of the tarp over the shelter he notices Ali holding it up out of line with the shelter on the other hand.

Zane (patting Carl on the back): I'll just leave you to hold that for a second.

As Carl nods once to show he's got it, Zane walks over to Ali who is standing on a log to help her reach high enough to hold up the tarp.

Zane (condescendingly): You just have to move the tarp along a little bit more Ali... it's not sitting on the shelter the way it should. See that big hole there (points to an area the tarp isn't covering). That's all going to leak if you don't cover it.

Ali (unphased by Zane's attitude): Yeah, alright, I see.

Ali lifts the tarp over to cover the shelter properly. Zane gives a satisfied nod and walks back over to Carl to show him how to tie the knot correctly. Kathy walks up to Ali after Zane leaves, shaking her head.

Kathy: I see that our self-elected leader over here has you hard at work.

Ali looks down and nods with a smile.

Kathy (sarcastically): Waoh, better not lose focus, we wouldn't want the shelter to leak.

Ali laughs as Kathy grins slyly.

Zane looks over and notices how little Kathy is doing.

Zane: Kathy, what are you doing?

Kathy jumps a little, not expecting Zane to have taken any notice in her.

Kathy (smirking): Just lightening the mood, I thought that was maybe one of the jobs you couldn't do very well so decided to take over.

Zane: Well it's not exactly needed right now, could you pass me some of that twine instead.

Kathy rolls her eyes and picks up the twine to give to Zane.

Kathy (passing Zane the twine): Here you go... just a quick question though why are you bossing us around? We voted Joe leader, not you. If I'm gonna be bossed around like a slave I want to have it done to me by someone I voted to do it to me. Or does that not work in your monarchy?

Jacob tries to hide his smile as he finds amusement in Kathy's antics. As Kathy speaks she gets progressively more agitated by her own words and Zane decides he doesn't want any of her back chatting.

Zane: Alright, I've had enough of your rudeness, it's not helpful and no one wants to hear. I'll tell you what if you want to b***h and be lazy you can do so, but not here.

Kathy rolls her eyes, aggravated.

Kathy (angrily): Fine! Whatever, I won't. Kick me out of my own camp, sure!

Kathy storms off and Zane shakes his head letting out a loud sigh. No one else says anything, not wanting to cause further drama.

Zane (after Kathy is out of earshot): Good riddance. Now that she's gone we can get some actual work done.

Zane continues to instruct the rest of the tribe in what to do as they all work hard to get the tarp up.

The camera focuses on Joe who is trying to ignore the drama and focus on building the shelter.

The scene cuts to later when Jacob is sitting next to a sulking Kathy on the beach.

Jacob (acting concerned): How are you doing?

Kathy (wiping away tears): S**t. Just s**t.

Jacob (giving her a hug): I know, I know. It's ok, we're all with you here.

Kathy leans in to the hug and buries or head into Jacob's shoulders.

Jacob (as the hug ends and Kathy lifts her head): I gotta be honest, you're back chatting was pretty frikin hilarious.

Kathy (smiling weakly): Thanks... at least I can do something right.

Jacob: Oh I bet you can do more then that right... just say the word and Zane is outta here.

Kathy: Really?

Jacob (looking her in the eyes): Definitely.

Kathy (with a vicious grin): Let's vote his ass out of here then!

Kathy continues to flash her vicious smile as Jacob goes on to a different topic.

The camera focuses on Zane sleeping in the shelter, snoring and then cuts over to Kathy laughing at something Jacob said and then zooms out. The scene switches to the Kahoolawe beach and hones in on the tribe returning to their beach. A depressing atmosphere settles over the camp as Derek sets the flag down in the sand after a fourth straight loss for the tribe.

As the tribe gathers around the camp Derek speaks up with his plan.

Derek: I know that it sucks to lose again and all that but guys I think I have a plan.

The other castaways lean in to listen to what Derek has to say. Noticing he has his tribes attention, Derek begins to lay out his proposal.

Derek: I think... well first of all let me clear something up because I think we should all trust each other if we want to better our communication. I was a professional athlete and played NRL. I didn't want to lie to you guys but I was scared that you would all want me out if you knew that.

Pierce (shaking his head): No way man, thanks for being honest.

Some of the other castaways nod and agree as the camera focuses on Molly trying to keep a serious face.

Molly: Secondly, in every sport there's always a coach. Someone who knows the team and will be able to strategise for the games and stuff. I think we need a coach for our tribe or a new leader or something.

Molly (nodding along): I like that idea... I select Pierce.

Cindy (eyeing Derek off): I agree. Pierce would make a good leader, that is... if he wants to...

Everyone else besides Derek nods and look to Pierce.

Pierce: I mean sure I guess, I can do that.

Derek (unpleased): Alright, Pierce it is then. You're an athlete, you know how this'll work.

Pierce nods happily as the camera focuses on Cindy.

Sarah (jokingly): What do you want us to do know mister leader sir?

Pierce nods and laughs quickly before his face turns to a more serious expression.

As Pierce moves about the camp the camera focuses on Molly who is happily going about her chores.

The camera focuses on Derek as he passes by Pierce with a forced smile.

Derek (half-joking, half-serious): Better not stuff this up, wouldn't want to end up like Titan.

Pierce (feeling threatened but forcing a laugh): No we wouldn't, that's the last thing I plan on doing with my leadership.

The camera focuses on Derek looking jealously at Pierce before once more, fading out.