Board Thread:Season Rankings/@comment-24584422-20180611085656/@comment-24659809-20180908042856

(I'm filling in whenever there's a 48-hour gap and CSI has just posted. :) )

514. Ken McNickle- Season 33-Millennials vs Gen X

Sigghhhhh, oh Ken. Ken is a classic example of being a good, complex character early in the season, and once the merge hits, their edit drops completely. Ryan suffered from the same edit, and both were losing finalists. While both Ryan and Ken had different irritating portions of their character, they happened to have completely different strategies. Ken would have been PERFECT for an early season like Africa. But he was on Millennials vs. Gen X, a season with "trust clusters". A lot of the other people on MvGX played really hard, and Ken just refused to. His whole thing was loyalty, which is fine. You might not win in modern Survivor playing that way, but there's nothing wrong with it.

What's irritating is that after ALLLLL that, and he was in the final four, he had to decide to either whether to send David and Adam to rocks and stay loyal or to vote out David, but turn on him. I remember a confessional right before that tribal council, and Ken said something really hokey along the lines of, "I'll vote for Adam and David and Adam will fight like men. I have to stay loyal." Then despite ALL OF THAT, he voted out David! Like, yeah it was technically the right move, but he basically threw away any shred of a case to win by negating the consistency in his game. It was just hypocritical and stupid and I can't respect him for it.

Save - Rob Mariano (20)

I may not like Rob, but he was an incredible and major character in Heroes vs. Villains.