User blog comment:MartianManHunter14/When is a good time to have an All-Stars Season?/@comment-24248949-20140715104906

I'm not an expert, considering that I haven't even made my all-stars fanon yet, but what I suggest is to do what you feel like doing! If you're having a 20-player All-Stars season, and it's your fifth season, then you would be able to bring back five players per each previous season. Of course, this would prove difficult if there just aren't a lot of all-stars in a specific season. You wouldn't want to bring someone back simply for the sake of bringing them back!

I suggest, maybe closer to when you're about to create the page for the fifth season, to ask the fans of your fanon who they want back. If you get less than twenty different people in mind after that, then maybe push your season date back a little bit. ;)