Board Thread:Season Rankings/@comment-24584422-20180611085656/@comment-26896797-20180611130121

Cut- Phillip Sheppard (22)

652. Phillip Sheppard- Season 22- Redemption Island

Phillip is just awful. In both of his seasons but especially in Redemption Island. Some may say that he was fun in the premiere because of the “Francesqua” thing but I just found it try-hardy and disrespectful. Phillip wouldn’t admit it but he was as much as Rob’s fan-girl than Natalie T was. But unlike her, he hoarded most of the airtime bloating about how he was gonna make his big move and turn on Rob even though he followed every order of his. He also talked about his dead great grandfather and how he had reincarnated in him or something non-stop, which absolutely no one cared about. I mean the sole use of this storyline just shows how dire Redemption Island was. Phillip also got into multiple fights which would be fun if they actually had any impact on the season and if it didn’t create the worst episode of Survivor ever, aka “Rice Wars”, where he accused Steve of being a racist, and there’s been many racists on this show, but Steve certainly isn’t one of them. Phillip just did it to get airtime and kudos to him because he did, but at the same time, I don’t blame the editors for putting him in the spotlight because literally nothing else happened in those Nicaraguan beaches.

Saving- Zeke Smith (33)