Talk:A Gift of Good Intention/@comment-9258976-20190626141301/@comment-9949103-20190626165458

So there's a couple of people on Diadem who I think can immediately be ruled out for having the idol.

Derek obviously can't have it because he wasn't even on the tribe when it was found, thank God for that by the way.

And unless this is some Incepetion or Shutter Island shit then I don't think that Dakoda is actively playing mind games with the viewers and pretending like she doesn't have the idol.

I'm also not convinced that Walker somehow has it either. Given his personality and actions throughout this episode, Walker was way to desperate and convinced that he was going home to have an idol in his pocket. If he actually had the idol then would think he would be a lot more confident about his position in the game.

Also, Alejandro just got voted out and I think it's very unlikely that he would go home with the idol in his pocket without us knowing about it.

That leaves four: BG, January, Olivia, or Peter.

I'm not sure yet, but my two prime suspects are BG and Olivia and here is my reasoning  for each.

BG: From the moment that the scene with Dakoda finding and then losing the idol occurred, BG was one of the people I was the most suspicious. Seeing as he was with Dakoda when she first discovered the idol, it would have been all too easy for him to have noticed it too. Also, BG having a confessional right before the idol was placed into Alejandro's bag makes me wary of him as well. Maybe he felt a certain way about Alejandro and thought that, just as Jasmine did to Miranda in Myanmar, placing the blame of the idol on Alejandro would get him voted out. To me, he just seems very shady regarding the whole thing, especially seeing as how "behind the scenes" his character has been so far.

Olivia: If anyone had motive to put that idol in Alejandro's bag, it was Olivia. She blatantly campaigned for him to leave at this vote and if I recall, she was unaccounted for when Dakoda found the idol in Alejandro's bag. It would be very surprising given Olivia's whole persona of not caring about the strategic game that she would have found the idol, but the move itself is petty and chaotic enough for it to match the socialite's M.O. Olivia herself has been quite unpredicatable so far in terms of strategy so that fact alone could point to how and why she'd place her own idol into someone else's just for someone else to see.

Peter and January are candidates as well, but I just couldn't find any compelling reason for either of them to pull this kind of move.